In 1834, a lighthouse costing $25,000 was built to mark the entrance to the New Basin harbor. It began operating in 1838, but was listed as unrepairable by 1854. In 1855, it was rebuilt as a fifth order light on the keeper's dwelling at a cost of $6,000. In 1890, the lighthouse was discontinued, sold at auction, and torn down. A lantern hung from a pole in its place.

In 1901, this more familiar structure was erected on iron pilings with a fifth order lens. The lighthouse was moved to its present location circa 1910. The exterior was restored in 1976.

Courtesy of Louisiana Division/City Archives, New Orleans Public Library